Home/Exam prep/GED Reasoning Through Language Arts/Evaluating Arguments and Reasoning

GED RLA PRACTICE 5: EVALUATING ARGUMENTS AND REASONING

GED RLA-style · Adult education
Read both passages about the same public issue. Then answer questions that compare the arguments and evaluate the relevance, strength, and limits of the evidence. This is focused practice on selected GED RLA skills, not a full-length GED test.


READY TO PRACTICE? LET’S GO!

Read both passages about the same public issue. Then answer questions that compare the arguments and evaluate the relevance, strength, and limits of the evidence.

Questions 1–10
Passage 1 · Keep Sunday Library Hours

The city should keep the two library branches that opened on Sundays during a six-week trial. Each branch averaged 145 visits per Sunday, and library staff recorded that many visitors used computers or attended family programs. A voluntary survey collected 120 responses; 78 respondents said Sunday access was important to their household. These results show that the service is useful to a substantial group of residents. Keeping Sunday hours at the two trial branches would give families and workers who are unavailable during the week another chance to use library resources. The city should review the cost of staffing and utilities, but it should not dismiss the service simply because it operates on a weekend. A branch that serves residents who otherwise have limited access provides a public benefit that is not captured by weekday attendance figures alone.

Central Claim · Question 1
1. What is the main claim in Passage 1?
Evidence · Question 2
2. Which detail most directly supports the claim that residents used the Sunday service?
Evidence Limitation · Question 3
3. What is a limitation of the voluntary survey in Passage 1?
Inference · Question 4
4. Which group does the author of Passage 1 especially want readers to consider?
Author’s Reasoning · Question 5
5. Why does the author mention staffing and utility costs?
Passage 2 · Shift the Hours to Weekday Evenings

The city should not continue Sunday library hours without comparing them with other ways to extend access. During the same six-week period, the four branches that stayed open later on weekday evenings recorded an average of 62 visits per branch per evening. The Sunday trial took place at only two branches, and the number of visitors varied considerably from one branch to the other. The city also paid additional staffing and utility costs for the Sunday sessions, but the trial report did not compare the cost per visitor with the cost of keeping branches open later on weekdays. Residents who work weekends may benefit from Sunday hours, yet residents who work late on weekdays may need a different schedule. Before making a permanent change, the city should compare attendance, cost, and neighborhood needs across all branches. The best schedule may differ from one location to another.

Central Claim · Question 6
6. Which statement best expresses the main claim in Passage 2?
Comparing Evidence · Question 7
7. What information does Passage 2 provide that Passage 1 does not emphasize?
Evaluating Reasoning · Question 8
8. Which weakness does Passage 2 identify in the available cost information?
Common Ground · Question 9
9. Which point would both authors most likely agree with?
Most Supported Conclusion · Question 10
10. Based on both passages, which conclusion is best supported?
—
Correct answers
These are original GED RLA-style practice questions written for LearnEnglishFeelGood.com. They are not official GED questions or a full GED practice test. GED® is a registered trademark of GED Testing Service LLC. LearnEnglishFeelGood.com is not affiliated with or endorsed by GED Testing Service.

GED RLA practice tip When comparing arguments, identify what each author wants readers to believe. Then examine whether the evidence is reliable, relevant, and sufficient for the conclusion. A confident tone does not make an argument stronger.

About this exercise: This page practices selected Reading for Meaning, Identifying and Creating Arguments, or Grammar and Language skills using automatically marked multiple-choice questions. The GED RLA test includes other question formats and a 45-minute extended response; this collection does not attempt to reproduce the full test or the essay.
Premium Resources
Business English Conversations Online course ›
visit our famous ESL SHOP for affordable teaching
& learning materials
More great stuff
American idioms
Phrasal verbs
Varieties of English
Travel English
Language-specific grammar
Our other sites
BusinessEnglishSite.com
EnglishForMyJob.com
LearnSpanishFeelGood.com

Connect & follow
© 2006-2027 LearnEnglishFeelGood.com unless otherwise stated. Reposting our content online is not allowed. See our content policy.