Read each classroom discussion prompt and the student contributions. Choose the response, evidence, or revision that develops a clear and relevant contribution to the discussion. These are automatically scored writing-skills drills, not scored academic discussion responses.
Professor: Some universities record lectures and make the recordings available online. Do you think all courses should offer lecture recordings?
1. Which contribution adds a clear position and a reason while engaging with the concern about attendance?
2. Which evidence would provide the strongest support for the claim that recordings can improve learning?
3. Which response addresses Jordan’s concern while proposing a practical course design?
4. Which conclusion is most carefully supported by the two comments?
Professor: Should every undergraduate degree require students to complete an internship before graduation?
5. Which contribution develops a balanced position and adds a practical proposal?
6. Which evidence would most directly test Marcus’s concern about unequal access?
7. Which response acknowledges Elena’s point while adding a meaningful qualification?
8. Which claim goes beyond what the discussion can establish?
Professor: In group projects, should every member receive the same grade, or should individual contributions affect the grade?
9. Which contribution advances the discussion by addressing both teamwork and individual accountability?
10. Which example would provide the clearest evidence of an unequal distribution of work?
11. Which response acknowledges Priya’s point before qualifying it?
12. Which criterion would make an individual contribution record most informative?