Read texts A–D and compare their opinions. For each question, choose the writer whose view is most similar to or different from the writer named. A writer may be selected more than once.
Supporters of the pedestrian scheme often point to higher visitor numbers and photographs of busy cafés as proof that local businesses are benefiting. I am not convinced by that evidence: visitor counts show how many people pass through, not whether they spend locally. The council should compare trading figures across several seasons and include shops just outside the closed area. In my view, economic effects are the most useful measure of whether the scheme is working.
I favour reducing private traffic, but the order of changes matters. Reliable buses, safe cycling routes and accessible drop-off points need to be in place before restrictions become permanent. Otherwise, the policy risks making daily journeys harder for residents who have fewer alternatives. A pilot should be judged by whether people with different mobility needs can still reach local services.
The debate has become too focused on whether the scheme attracts shoppers. I agree that visitor numbers alone tell us little about whether local businesses are better off; however, commercial data should not be the main test of success. A street should also be judged by whether people can cross it safely, rest comfortably and use it without feeling pressured to buy something. Benches, shade and level pavements matter even when nobody makes a purchase.
Closing a central street can make the area look calmer while shifting congestion into nearby residential roads. Traffic counts should cover the surrounding district, not just the newly pedestrianised section. I would support a permanent scheme only after that wider impact had been measured. The council should also test bus routes and accessible drop-off points beyond the restricted streets before making the change permanent.
1. Which writer has a similar view to Writer A on the significance of visitor numbers when assessing whether local businesses have benefited?
2. Which writer has a similar view to Writer B on the need to provide practical transport and access alternatives before a scheme becomes permanent?
3. Which writer has a different view from Writer C about what should be the main measure of a pedestrian scheme’s success?
4. Which writer shares Writer A’s view that an assessment should consider effects beyond the streets directly covered by the scheme?